ETF Vs Mutual Fund: Difference Between ETF & Mutual Fund

Now, this will probably not make a difference for long-term users. But if you wish to indulge in intraday trading or use the stock market features such as Stop-Loss and Market Orders, these are not possible. An index fund works like an MF, in which a fund manager creates a portfolio that replicates an index, which could be the Sensex or Nifty.

But Index Funds give you various options to suit your financial needs like growth option for long-term goals versus dividend option for regular income. You can also invest regularly in smaller amounts through SIP in an Index Fund. You also don’t need a Demat account to invest in Index Funds unlike ETFs. The stocks mentioned in this article are not recommendations.

  • Each time you wish to invest in an ETF, you will need to do it deliberately, which can be cumbersome and easy to miss.
  • For example, in India if a normal index fund has an expense ratio of 1.25% then an index ETF would have an expense ratio of just about 0.35%.
  • At the end of the day, however, you will get the closing NAV of the ETF.

EWithout having a trading and demat account with a stock broker, you cannot invest in ETFs. However for any reason, if you are unable to open a trading and demat account, you can invest in “ETF like” investment products where you can invest in a passive fund which tracks an index. These are called Index funds which like ETFs aim to track a particular index like Sensex, Nifty, BSE – 100, Nifty 100, Bank Nifty etc.

What are Mutual Funds?

Determining which is right for you depends on numerous factors and your own personal preferences, such as your tolerance for high expense ratios or preference for stock orders. Since ETFs are like traded stocks, the dividends are directly credited to your registered bank account. This is a hassle from a financial planning point of view as the dividends have to be manually reinvested. In case of index funds, you can opt for a growth plan where dividends are automatically reinvested. An index fund purchase or redemption will be executed at the end-of-day NAV.

Investors can buy or sell shares all day, whereas index mutual fund trades are all settled in bulk at the end of the day at the net asset value of shares at the market close. If the underlying assets tank in price mid-day but come back by the end of trading, there’s no way for index mutual fund investors to capitalize on that drop. An Index ETF, on the other hand, is composed of fractional shares of the index.

etfs vs index funds

It is managed by fund managers who trade on behalf of the investor and ensure that there is minimum loss or no loss in the investment value with maximization of profit. Both the Index ETF and the Index fund run the market risk or Beta as we popular call it. Firstly, there is the tracking error risk which is higher in case of index funds compared to ETFs as index funds need to keep larger cash balance to handle redemptions. But Index ETFs run a higher risk of bid-ask spreads widening when markets get volatile.

What are the different types of ETFs available in India?

Therefore, the unavailability of the SIP route in ETFs is a serious handicap, as the SIP route remains a very disciplined and steady way for investors to participate in the equity markets. So, if you are one of those investors who are more comfortable investing in equities using the SIP route, then presently, Index Funds might be the right way to go about it. Systematic investment plans or SIPs are a popular method of investing for retail investors, with monthly inflows consistently crossing the Rs. 8,000 crore mark for many months now. While Index Funds offer the SIP facility, ETFs generally do not offer a SIP option.

Index Funds are passively managed instruments, but ETFs can be passively managed or actively managed funds. As it stands, about 20% of the ETFs in the United States are actively managed ETFs. This means there is an investment team that is researching companies and making tactical decisions on how to build the ETF’s portfolio, which stocks to buy, which stocks to sell, etc. Mutual funds are actively managed by expert fund managers or teams, but they are index-tracking as well.

Tiger ETF

Index funds can be bought just like any other mutual fund scheme but their expense ratio is slightly higher than Exchange traded funds. In mutual funds, the AMC acts as counterparty to the investor. Investors do their buy / sell transactions with the AMC whereas ETFs are listed on stock exchanges like shares. Investors can buy or sell ETFs in the stock exchange at a real time price.

etfs vs index funds

To understand index funds, we first need to get a clear understanding of indexes. In financial terms, an index is a statistical measure windsor brokers review of a security or a market. If you find both ETFs and index funds aligning with your financial goals, you can invest in both.

In India generally index funds have an expense ratio of 1.25% while index ETFs have an expense ratio of about 0.35%. In addition, when you buy and sell the index ETF you are also liable to pay the brokerage and other statutory costs like GST, STT, stamp duty, exchange fees, SEBI turnover tax etc. Index funds are for investors who want to keep their equity investment simple. These funds follow a passive investment strategy, as they simply mirror the benchmark. When it comes to transaction in index funds, it is the responsibility of the mutual fund house to allocate units for purchase transaction and to honour redemption requests.

ETF vs Index Fund: What’s the Difference?

Index mutual funds allow shareholders to automatically reinvest dividends paid out by the fund back into more shares. Since mutual funds keep their own records, investors who opt to reinvest their dividends will see transactions happen the same day the dividend is paid out. Index mutual funds don’t require investors to pay a commission to invest in the fund. Granted, there are index mutual funds available with small minimum investment requirements. These funds typically track a broad market index and are very popular. That said, index mutual funds are also incredibly tax-efficient.

Those high expense ratios often wipe out any excess returns the portfolio manager is able to produce. In fact, most actively managed mutual funds underperform their benchmark indexes over time when including expenses. ETFs are suited for intraday trades, limit or stop orders and short-selling but if you are not one of those who likes to time the market, index funds are for you. While frequent transactions can raise commission costs and lower your return from ETFs, they also tend to have lower expense ratio compared to Index Funds.

They try to match the returns as well as price movements shown in the index. Before Winvesta, Swastik was a Director at Deutsche Bank where he ran a multi-billion EUR global trading book on multi-asset products. Paying a higher fee can quickly add up, especially if the fund is not outperforming as much as the extra fee it is charging compared to gann trend indicator a benchmark ETF. As an example, If you paid 0.30% fees per year rather than 1.50% p.a., after 5 years you will be 6% better off. Since it mirrors the Index, the fund performance will likely be similar to the returns generated by the Index. Check your securities / MF / bonds in the consolidated account statement issued by NSDL/CDSL every month.

In today’s world, it’s difficult for investors to find the time to look after their investments. They usually find ways to invest in passive investment streams, in which their money is managed by professional fund managers who invest and trade on their behalf. One of the most popular methods of investing inequity funds is through the systematic investment plan.

What are disadvantages of ETFs?

  • Trading fees. Although ETFs generally have lower costs compared to some other investments, such as mutual funds, they're not free.
  • Operating expenses.
  • Low trading volume.
  • Tracking errors.
  • Potentially less diversification.
  • Hidden risks.
  • Lack of liquidity.
  • Capital gains distributions.

However, the option to opt for the SIP mode of investment, a disciplined approach to wealth creation, is unavailable in case of ETFs. ETFs can be found on all major stock exchanges and are traded during the equity trading time. The share price of ETFs is derived from the cost of the underlying assets. The value of dividends earned by the shareholders depends on the performance and asset management of the ETF company. The fund manager, instead of selecting stocks and trying to create alpha for you, just creates a portfolio that replicates an index .

What are the differences between ETFs and index funds?

ETFs and index funds have several similarities but work on different approaches. While they are both passive investment vehicles, there are some significant differences between ETFs and index funds. Here’s how ETFs and index funds differ across various parameters:

Objective: The main aim of ETFs is to track the performance of specific indices of an exchange. Index funds, on the other hand, replicate the performance of the underlying index as is.

Trading: While index funds are issued in units like other mutual funds, ETFs are traded much like stocks on a stock exchange.

Pricing: The pricing of ETFs follows the same principle as shares. In contrast, the Net Asset Value (NAV) of index funds varies due to multiple factors.

Influencing factors: In the case of ETFs, the demand and supply of securities affect the price. In the case of index funds, the NAV of the fund and the underlying assets impact the price.

Cost: A transactional fee is applicable when you invest in ETFs, while index…  More

ETFs are highly transparent in nature, where investors get to know exactly where their investments are allocated. These can be traded on exchanges like stocks, purchased and sold anytime investors wish. They are lower in cost, and this makes them good bets for initial fresh investors. ETFs also prove to be more efficient where taxation is concerned. Assess your risk appetite, financial objective, and investment horizon to determine whether to invest in an actively managed fund or passive fund, or a combination of both. Advisably, you should avoid sector-oriented passive funds if you do not have a very high risk appetite.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: